I've noticed coverage of "leadership" in IT magazines recently, but I'm not comfortable with the approach they take. For example, this editorial in CIO Magazine titled
Leadership Isn't a Fairy Tale After All has "Personal attention and hands-on involvement can make good IT managers great IT leaders" as the subtitle. The text then says:
Our story spells out detailed tactics and practical ideas that CIOs can use to turn good IT managers into potentially great IT leaders...
You’ll notice a strong thread of personal attention and hands-on involvement from the very top at the companies developing a strong bench of future leaders.
At REDACTED, for example, the CEO walks the walk on one-to-one leadership development by holding regular career conversations with his senior leadership team. His CIO, REDACTED, then makes sure that style of direct communication flows downward to the IT team. “If you don’t take time to talk to people about their professional development,” REDACTED notes, “it just doesn’t get done.”
REDACTED is another bright light in this realm with a program called The Lab, which fosters leadership development across various business units by bringing together 30 of them at a time to form strategic problem-solving teams.
And at REDACTED, CIO REDACTED connects on a more personal level, emailing coffee-talk questions to her global staff every two weeks to get conversations going on everything from personal dreams to world views.
In my opinion, "regular career conversations" are a form of coaching, not leadership. Forming "strategic problem-solving teams" is management, not leadership. Finally, "emailing coffee-talk questions" is banter, not leadership.
So what are the five qualities of leadership, at least in my experience?
- Leaders develop and execute a vision; they do not follow trends set by others.
- Leaders embody strong core values and do not sacrifice those core values in order to advance their personal careers.
- Leaders' actions demonstrate a focus on their people, not themselves, and that focus on the people takes care of the mission.
- Leaders work to "make their people look good," rather than making the boss or themselves look good.
- In the darkest hours, leaders put themselves personally at risk for the good of their team.
Notice the contrast between these five principles and the previous guidance. My focus is on actions, whereas the other ideas focus on communication. I do not discount the value of communication, but with leadership the deeds matter far more than the words. It is helpful to have coaching, mentoring, managing, and so forth, but these concepts are separate from leadership.
If you're wondering about the image for this post, I wanted to show a picture from the movie
We Were Soldiers, based on the
book by Lt Gen Hal Moore and Joe Galloway. Then Lt Col Moore (portrayed by Mel Gibson) always landed with his air cavalry troops, in the first helicopter, and was the first person to step foot on adversary soil. He was also the last person to leave. As he wrote:
When we step on the battlefield, I will be The First Boots On and the Last Boots Off.
And he didn't just say it, he did it. That's a leader.
